Henry Blogdet's recently ran an article for Business Insider titled, IT'S OFFICIAL: Android Clobbering Everyone, iPhone Dead In The Water. To get a better idea of what he is talking about feel free to check out his column here. Am I going to rip into Henry's column from the get-go? Absolutely. I found his entire piece seriously troubling, as I had thought that only a Dvorak-like mind could come up with such antiquated material – I was wrong.
I'm not here to personally tear apart Henry, that's not my goal, as I enjoyed his latest column on the economy as it was quite refreshing. But whether Henry's mobile OS mindset comes from a financial or viable business perspective it makes no difference, his positions are completely indefensible. It actually took some time to decipher whether or not he was actually serious. Was this just another Paul Thurott link bait article, or did Henry really think he'd struck gold with this one? Sadly, I think it's the latter, which means I'm putting in the midnight oil to give Henry – and hopefully tens of thousands more – pause to reflect as to why this isn't the PC war of decades past, rather, it is the new war of post PC devices, and how the twixt of these twain couldn't be further apart.
iOS vs Android: The Financial War That Isn't
Equating Android's rapid rise in market share as being some form of financial windfall for Google while a colossal loss for Apple is pure rhetoric that has no teeth. Google let Android find its way in the world via open source. Google's only hope in making money on this venture is for search and Android marketplace related income. It is said that Google is bringing in revenues of about $1 billion per-year with Android. At this rate, if Google captured the entire cell phone industry it wouldn't make more than $10 billion a year, at best...
Making matters worse, millions of Android copies are fitted onto smartphones in China, but are fitted using the China-based Baidu search engine. These devices have no Android marketplace for application purchases and most importantly to Google, there is no ad revenue pouring into the search giant due to Baidu's massive China dominance.
China is a massive growth engine for the mobile space, and Google is having very little financial success in the greater region.. Meanwhile, Apple is exploding in sales, profits and revenues from millions of new customers within China. Strangely, China gets lost on Blodget's arguments.
This past quarter, Apple sold over 18 million iPhones, driving around $11 billion in revenues for Apple, Inc. There is simply no case to be made that Google's Android is beating down Apple financially using mobile OS wars as an example. At least during the Mac vs PC battle Microsoft was making windfall profits on Windows licensing while Apple took it in the shorts, but nothing could be further from the truth in the mobile OS wars going on today.
iOS vs Android: The Platform War That Isn't
I was glad to see Henry talking about Android being a fractured platform, but somehow he believes Google is going to solve this problem so there's simply nothing to worry about. Uh, ever watch Google throw mud at a wall to see if it sticks? Google pours out programs like a flood, and if these initiatives fail they are all but left for dead. Kevin Bacon and GoogleTV anyone?...
Analysts and tech pundits alike still seem to be missing the concept that Android isn't tightly controlled by Google, nor can it be due to it's very open source nature. If Android were the platform it's been made out to be it would be like Windows, where an application would be written once, and deployed on any Windows machine.
But Android continues to move further and further away from this purist platform model. With Android, it's more about developing for a specific device, a particular chipset and screen size, and taking advantage of any given number of physical buttons - or not - on said device. Android developers are designing for devices, not a pure software platform, that's just the way it is, and it isn't going to get any better any time soon.
Part II continues tomorrow with:
iOS vs Android: The Market Share War That Is
NOTE: Mark Reschke owns shares of Apple, Inc (AAPL).
- Apple's quiet but steady improvements to the butterfly keyboard
- Stop the Insanity! Did Apple's iPhones Sales Really Fall Last Quarter?!
- Stop The Fake News! iPhone X's OLED Display Is NOT Just Like Any Other Samsung Offering
- iPhone X: Android Publications Can't Get Enough Of It
- Apple Gears Up at Costco, Just In Time For Christmas
- NY Times David Pogue Gets Why Apple TV 4K is the Best Streaming Box On The Market
- iPhone X: The Good, The Bad And The Ugly
- Absolutely The Best Feature Change In iPhone X
- Apple Gets the Millennial and Journalists Don't Like It
- Apple's Best Hidden Talent Resides Within Their Silicon Team